Zaylie Windsor made a stunning comeback on American Idol, proving her critics wrong — including judge Luke Bryan — with a standout performance that may have secured her a spot in the show’s Top 10.
During Sunday night’s Showstopper episode on April 6, Windsor, 20, had a lot to prove. She had received a “no” from Bryan during her initial audition, casting doubt on her future in the competition. But this time, she came ready to show what she was truly capable of.
“This is probably the biggest audience I’ve ever performed for. I’m really nervous about holding back on stage again like I did in my audition,” Windsor said before stepping into the spotlight.
At her first audition, Windsor performed an original song titled The Used. While Bryan felt she wasn’t “quite ready” for the next level, fellow judge Carrie Underwood saw promise and gave her a shot.
“There’s a Taylor Swift quality to her. She might not have that big, belting voice, but there’s something special there,” Underwood explained. “I think she has a lot more to show us.”
Determined to prove herself, Windsor selected Billie Eilish’s Happier Than Ever for her Showstopper performance — a bold choice that she admitted came with pressure.
“I tend to get super nervous. Some of the notes are really high — not out of my range, but definitely out of my comfort zone,” she said during rehearsals. “With a song this big, you can’t hold back. If you do, it just doesn’t land.”
Despite the nerves, Windsor delivered a stunning rendition, beginning softly and then unleashing her full vocal power. The performance earned her a standing ovation from all three judges.
“You won me over and confirmed me,” said judge Lionel Richie, praising her growth and confidence.
Underwood was just as impressed, smiling and saying, “Welcome to the Zaylie show.”
And in a surprising twist, even Bryan changed his tune.
“She’s serious,” he said. “She’s definitely put herself in the Top 10.”
American Idol continues Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.
Related topics:
